Margariteros kitchen

Margarita: classic, Tommy’s, passionfruit or Mezcalita?

Margariteros · 13 November 2026

A classic margarita combines tequila, lime and triple sec. In the International Bartenders Association’s Tommy’s Margarita, agave nectar takes the place of the liqueur. That is the first useful distinction when reading a cocktail menu. Passionfruit introduces another fruit, while Mezcalita points towards a separate option within the world of agave-spirit cocktails.

At Margariteros, Chmielna 7/9 in Warsaw, you will find all four names. This guide separates reference recipes from the descriptions in our own menu and explains what to compare: sweetening ingredient, citrus, base spirit and serving style. It gives you a more specific way to order than simply asking for something Mexican.

Citrus cocktail in a coupe glass with lime and a partial salt rim
Illustration based on Margariteros photographs; the current serving may differ.

Where does the margarita come from? A printed clue from 1937

Rather than choosing one colourful origin story, start with a surviving book. The Café Royal Cocktail Book, compiled by W. J. Tarling in 1937, includes a Picador on page 146: tequila, Cointreau and fresh lime or lemon juice, shaken together. It is a documented earlier recipe with ingredients close to the modern margarita. Source: digitised original, page 146.

That entry does not settle who invented the cocktail under the name Margarita. Nor does it prove that Tarling created the Picador: the book is a collection of recipes. What it establishes is that this combination of tequila, citrus and Cointreau had been published. One detail is particularly revealing: the historical recipe permits lemon, whereas the modern IBA Margarita specifies lime. They are not identical instructions.

Two modern reference recipes: IBA

The International Bartenders Association publishes separate specifications for Margarita and Tommy’s Margarita:

Ingredient · IBA Margarita · IBA Tommy’s Margarita

Ingredient: Tequila 100% agave · IBA Margarita: 50 ml · IBA Tommy’s Margarita: 60 ml

Ingredient: Fresh lime juice · IBA Margarita: 15 ml · IBA Tommy’s Margarita: 30 ml

Ingredient: Triple sec · IBA Margarita: 20 ml · IBA Tommy’s Margarita: Not listed

Ingredient: Agave nectar · IBA Margarita: Not listed · IBA Tommy’s Margarita: 30 ml

Sources: IBA Margarita, IBA Tommy’s Margarita. These are published reference recipes, rather than the declared proportions of a Margariteros house preparation.

Look at the complete columns when comparing them. The change is not limited to the sweetening ingredient: the lime and tequila quantities also differ. It would therefore be misleading to describe Tommy’s simply as adding agave nectar to a finished classic margarita. If you are making a reference version at home, follow one specification instead of combining pieces of both.

How is a classic margarita made?

The IBA method is straightforward:

  1. Measure the ingredients for the chosen recipe.
  2. Put them in a shaker with ice.
  3. Shake and strain into a chilled cocktail glass.
  4. Optionally use salt on part of the rim.

The IBA Tommy’s is also shaken, but is strained into a chilled rocks glass containing ice and garnished with lime. This serving detail is useful when ordering: the recipe name and serving description tell you more than the shape of a glass in a photograph.

Salt is not a compulsory ingredient in the liquid of the classic specification. If you prefer to avoid it or want part of the rim left unsalted, mention that before preparation. There is no need to assume that every margarita must arrive with exactly the same decoration.

Agave in tequila and agave nectar are different things

The Consejo Regulador del Tequila describes tequila as a Mexican spirit with a designation of origin, made from the blue variety of Agave tequilana Weber. The term 100% agave concerns the source of the sugars used to produce the spirit. Source: CRT — Our Tequila.

Agave nectar in a Tommy’s Margarita is a separate cocktail ingredient. Do not confuse it with the wording on the tequila label: a recipe can contain both 100% agave tequila and added agave nectar. The terms answer different questions. One describes the spirit; the other identifies something added when mixing the drink.

For that reason, asking about both the base and the additions is useful. “With agave” does not describe an entire cocktail. It does not establish the finished sweetness, serving size or the way that particular preparation will taste alongside its lime juice.

What changes in a Tommy’s Margarita?

In the reference version, triple sec disappears and agave nectar takes its place. The distinction is more useful than a blanket promise that Tommy’s is less sweet. The finished balance depends on the whole recipe, and the table also shows a different quantity of citrus. A practical question is whether you want the classic combination containing liqueur or a version whose sweetening ingredient is agave.

Our Tommy’s Margarita menu description emphasises agave and lime, with a tart, fresh and slightly dry character. That is the description read on 13 November 2026. It does not publish a complete house ingredient list or proportions, so the IBA specification explains the cocktail name here rather than documenting our exact build. If one ingredient determines your choice, check it with the bar before ordering.

Passionfruit Margarita: fruit does not automatically mean dessert

Our Passion Fruit Margarita description brings together passionfruit and lime freshness. The menu calls it tropical, tart and juicy. It is a useful direction for someone who wants a fruit variation but is not simply choosing the sweetest-sounding drink.

The name alone does not identify whether a preparation uses juice, purée or another form of fruit, or how much sweetening ingredient is added. Our menu does not give those details. When speaking to the bartender, explain what interests you: a citrus-led drink, the passionfruit element, or a less sweet balance. That is more precise than treating the word fruity as a complete flavour scale.

Why compare Mezcalita separately?

Mezcal is a Mexican agave spirit. Its official definition connects its character with factors including the species of agave and the production process; the word is not simply the name of one smoky flavour. Source: NOM-070-SCFI-2016, section 3.17.

Our Mezcalita appears as a variation on Margarita, described as smoky, citrus-led and intense. That profile belongs to the drink described in our menu. We do not apply it to every mezcal, and the cocktail name does not publish the brand or proportions of the base used. If a particular bottle interests you, or you want to understand its difference from tequila, ask about the current base spirit.

Choosing at the Margariteros bar

Begin with the direction that appeals to you:

  • Margarita: tequila, lime and a tart, citrus-led character in our description.
  • Tommy’s Margarita: agave and lime, described as slightly dry.
  • Passion Fruit Margarita: passionfruit and lime, tropical and tart.
  • Mezcalita: a separate option described as smoky and citrus-led.

These descriptions come from the Margariteros cocktail menu, read on 13 November 2026. They are a starting point for ordering, rather than the results of a comparative tasting conducted for this article. Ask about the base spirit, sweetening ingredient and whether the serving comes over ice if those details matter to you.

For an alcohol-free choice, browse the separate alcohol-free options. Do not assume that omitting one ingredient automatically turns a classic margarita into a complete 0% cocktail. Ask about ingredients before ordering if you have an allergy, and use the current menu for prices.

Find Margariteros at Chmielna 7/9 in Warsaw. Browse the cocktails, explore an evening at the bar, or open the booking form.

Sources

Recipes and methods: the International Bartenders Association’s Margarita and Tommy’s Margarita. History: the original 1937 Café Royal Cocktail Book, page 146, also checked against the scanned page. Spirit definitions: CRT and the identified section of NOM-070. Descriptions of our four options: the Polish and English Margariteros menu. Sources and menu were checked on 13 November 2026; reference-cocktail information is kept distinct from the description of our own bar.

View the current menu